Rank the albums

Ok, so, if this is already a thread, I apologize. In that case, just ignore/delete this one and point me to the right place. But, anyways, rank the albums from favorite to least favorite. If you wanna include demos and the live stuff that's fine. Here's mine:

SATQ > American Slang > Sink or Swim > 59 Sound

Also, if you wanna explain the reasoning behind your list, that's cool too.

this is too difficult for me to choose.
because i love all of their albums for such different reasons.

really hard one but here goes

american slang - 59 sounds - sink or swim - SATQ

senor would be higher if was longer

SATQ
59S
SOS
AS

But honestly, I'd give them all a 10/10 or something if I were the music reviewer type.

I'll play.

1. Senor and The Queen
2. American Slang (Right now)
3.The 59 Sound
4. Sink or Swim

Agreed! I love them all and they are all powerful and amazing! However each has a very distinct sound. This ranking is based on my preference of styles:

S&TQ
SOS
59S
AS

1. Sink or Swim
2. 59 Sound
3. Senior and the Queen
4. American Slang

Senor and the Queen always comes first, I love that EP so much.
And I can never choose between Sink or Swim or '59 Sound. Liking one more than the other depends on what mood i'm in.


(leaving out AS because i'm still waiting to hear it...)

1. Sink or Swim
2. Senor and the Queen
3. American Slang
4. '59 Sound

But like most people have said they would all get a 10/10.

Hmmmm, I don't really wanna include SAtQ as it's so short. But if that's what we're doing then mine would be:

1. SoS
2. AS
= SAtQ
4. 59S

haha, that's somehow like putting m & m's in alphabeticl order^^, kinda hard

My ranking:
1) Sink Or Swim
2) American Slang
3) The 59 Sound
4) Senor And The Queen


i first prefered t59s, but then sos and their ep started growing on me so much that i prefer them now over t59s. the reason why satq is placed last rank is cause of the low number of songs on the ep.

did not really know how to place as here, caus it usually takes lotta time for me til i can say which record i really like. but as has already grown so very much on me^^

Pleasantly surprised at the number of people that like SATQ as much as me. I started thinking about this because I find it that with this new album I like 59 Sound less and less. I mean, of course I still love it, but it just seems to be my least favorite out of everything they've put out. I was listening to it at work today and the whole time I was just wishing I were listening to American Slang instead. I probably won't go back to it for a long time. But, anyways, I know quite a few passive gaslight fans who have never listened to SATQ and if you're one of them correct that mistake asap! Keep the rankings coming!

being one of the handful of folks who haven't heard AS yet, my list cannot contain it, but i suppose it would go-

SATQ
Sink or Swim
59 Sound

But the records could flip flop in order...in changes. I am surprised to see so many of us here favor SATQ!!

1. SoS
2. SatQ
3. '59S
4. AS

1. The '59 Sound
2. Senor And The Queen
3. American Slang
4. Sink Or Swim

1. SOS
2. AS
3. T'59S

I dont want to rank SATQ as its tough to compare 4 songs with a full album

1. 59 sound
2. SoS
3. AS
4. SaTQ

i only got AS this week...have listened to it constantly since I got a copy and think that it will prob be my favourite in a few weeks but have played the others so many times over the last couple of years that it is difficult to say

....like a few others have said...they are all 10/10

SATQ
SoS
59 sound
American Slang

Though I could be tempted to swap SoS and 59 around.

1.SOS
2.SATQ
3.59'sound
4.AS

I used to prefer SoS and SATQ over 59S but I've kind of mellowed out lately. At the moment I'd say:

1) The '59 Sound
2) American Slang
3) Sink Or Swim
4) Senor And The Queen

Not that I dislike SATQ, not at all, but if I were to take only 3 TGA albums to a deserted island (you know the drill =P) it'd be the one I'd leave out I suppose.

1. SoS / AS
2. T59S
3. SATQ / LAPA

Only doing studio releases.

1. The '59 Sound
2. American Slang
3. Senor & The Queen
4. Sink or Swim

1. American Slang
2. SatQ
3. The '59 Sound
4. Sink or Swim

Not much space in between them, though.

Harry Lime wrote:

1. American Slang
2. SatQ
3. The '59 Sound
4. Sink or Swim

Not much space in between them, though.

I'd say this is mine, I hate putting SoS so low, but it's just.. yeah. Haha.

sink or swim
senor and the queen
american slang
59 sound.