The Top 25 Gaslight Anthem Songs [the results are on page 5]

Alright everybody. It's time. Time to vote for the Top 25 Gaslight Anthem songs as of July 2010. Here are the rules:

1. Vote for 25 and only 25 songs
2. Rank them 1-25. Points will be assigned so the higher the rank, the higher the points (ie Your favorite song gets 25 points, the 25th song gets 1 point)
3. Vote only for songs on Sink or Swim, Señor and the Queen, The '59 Sound, American Slang and Covers.
4. Live songs other than covers will not be counted. (ie Vote for Trusty Chords, not Trusty Chords live at wherever)

The deadline for voting will be August 1

Please email me your votes in a text or Word document with your ranks 1-25. When you email me your votes, post here that you've emailed them to me. Do not post your rankings here.

My email address is shapdaddy [at] gmail [dot] com.

Cheers! Can't wait to see what comes of this!

That was easier than I expected! Just e-mailed it.

I'm having a much harder time...wow

just sent my picks

i didn't find it too hard, i already had a 25 song gaslight playlist, so i just had to sort them.

im going for the whole, delete from a playlist until i get 25 then order method. it's incredibly harder than i thought.

ps- i feel like a hipster trying to go through these songs. thinking which ones need the votes because others are popular.

finished it up and emailed

putting them in order by what i want to sing along to in my car on this, a day off work. Making the CD and going for a drive. Cheers.

IKeeptheDiner wrote:

im going for the whole, delete from a playlist until i get 25 then order method. it's incredibly harder than i thought.

Yeah, that's what I'm doing. It's rough. I got it down to 30 songs but I can't figure out which 5 to cut last.

EDIT: Ok, sent.

Sent. Not that hard, actually. Thought it would be impossible, though.

Finished and Sent!

Ugh. This is ridiculously hard.

This is what I imagine it would be like choosing between your children.

Wow, I'm a loser. I went through each album and picked the songs I thought would be contenders...that added up to 23. I figured it out though.

Email sent.

Figuring this out is gonna be tough. I think I'll use "I want to hear more of the AS stuff live" as an excuse to wait a few weeks =P

im in the finishing step. hearing if i put it in the right order. it'll be sent in and hour and 21 minutes.

I'm having a hard time slotting the AS songs. My faves on the album alone seem to change by the listen, so then to compare them to the stuff I've known and loved for so long … pretty difficult.

Done. Sound. Boom.

Done and sent.

Wasn't too hard. But I was surprised with my outcome lol.

Righty-ho, PHEW I'm done.
That really was difficult!

wherefore art thou elvis is my unequivocal number 1, the subsequent 24 might be tricky

...some time later - done

Bah, I started devouring American Slang yesterday and there are so many great songs there. My list will come in the last second if I'm able to decide.

My top 25 are on the way, via email. Coming up with the 25 wasn't the hard part, ranking them was.

It's really interesting looking at the numbers so far. I'd make some joke here but I don't want to influence any kind of voting.

I'm gonna do a huge statistical breakdown of it all hopefully when voting's over.

when do we find out/whens the last day to submit our top 25?

Deadline is August 1.