Coming soon - The Top 25 Gaslight Anthem Songs

Or we could wait until they release a few more albums and call it 59...

But in all seriousness, 25 seems to make the most sense to me.

Sounds like a great idea, count me in!

25 for sure!

Lets just do Sos, S&TQ, 59, and AS. But do every song on there ranked. That was we can see how people feel about every song they have released.

yeh 25 sounds good to me

After a resounding vote, 25 songs it is.

25 is cut throat...I love it! Haha
I should probably start thinking about my list now since it'll probably take me 50 or so days to decide the order of my favorites!
Great idea btw!

Haha, this is gonna be hard

I did mine yesterday, because I figured if I didn't knock it off immediately I'd overthink it and completely muck up the list, although that's admittedly near impossible to do with a band of TGA's caliber.

i vote for top 25 songs, including brian's solo stuff, but excluding this charming man cause i don't think it would be apporpriate.


basically this idea sounds fun. but how do you imagine this should work? is everyone allowed to vote just once oder as often as they want?

Like I said before, I think the best bet is to have everyone make a list of 1-25. Everyone's number 1 choice gets 25 points, their number 2 gets 24, etc etc.

Then you add up the total number of points for each song and then list them that way. I'd list the point totals too so we can see how big the differences were. In the event of a tie, you take which ever song had more higher placed votes.

Edit: They can submit them in PMs too so no one knows the results! It's pretty easy too, this way it's just legit adding point totals instead of trying to rank everything.

so are we just doing Gaslight songs or Brians solo stuff aswell?

well it's called top 25 tga songs...

Daire wrote:

well it's called top 25 tga songs...

sorry its just someone said about including Brians stuff

rikerd18 wrote:

Daire wrote:

well it's called top 25 tga songs...

sorry its just someone said about including Brians stuff

Haha. Sorry if that came across a bit dickish. Wasn't meant like that at all. (Though I can clearle see how it seems that way!)

Daire wrote:

rikerd18 wrote:

Daire wrote:

well it's called top 25 tga songs...

sorry its just someone said about including Brians stuff

Haha. Sorry if that came across a bit dickish. Wasn't meant like that at all. (Though I can clearle see how it seems that way!)

no worries mate

Building hype

So when will this be happening?

Bigtittykitty wrote:

So when will this be happening?

i assume not till late june. so non-leakers can add some AS songs. i'm sure there will be notice of it for forum members. just a suggestion; what if we make it one week only people have to decide. like july 1-7, so people can digest AS (and bonus tracks) properly.

i don't think i could do it, personally. each song is awesome to me at different times. i have my faves but, i wouldn't like to think of any as less than another. just my opinion

this should be fun

This is getting closer. Start thinking about those lists!

I tried putting a rough list together and damn I did not realize how challenging it is

Vibes wrote:

This is getting closer. Start thinking about those lists!

when will official submissions be allowed?

Even without AS this is really hard. Be so much easier if we could just do "Top 5" "Next 5" etc.. but then we'd be much more likely to get ties. *has his current number 1 picked out but stuff can easily change in 2 months*