The Sunday Paper in Georgia

http://www.sundaypaper.com/More/Archives/tabid/98/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/3182/THE-GASLIGHT-ANTHEM.aspx

just read this review that actually says "Ultimately, the melodies aren’t strong enough to support the words, reverbed guitars and busy arrangements, most of which get repetitious as the disc winds into its final third."

un-frickin-believable

i guess it's just impossible to have everyone on our side. w/e, it's just one guy's opinion.

if one of my friends told me that he did not like TGA, I would have no problem with that, he is just one person. However when you write for a paper some people will follow what you say, and the comments are our only way of trying to demenish the influence of that person.

well, i was actually talking about the fact that there were way more positive reviews of the record in the media itself. people should definitely look at those reviews instead of this one, but i see what you're saying.

oh my bad, I completely mistook what you said...

With simple editing mistakes like 'Gashlight' and 'Edg,e' it's hard to take this guy seriously. Yes, splitting hairs, I know.

All he states is that it's 2.5 stars. 2.5 out of what? 2.5 stars out of 2.5, thank you, sir.

is it written by a relation to benny?!

ktp, I was just going to bring that up.

That publication is a joke. The editor should be fired and the writer needs his eyes checked with all of those typos and the shoddy way it all came out. Somebody's not doing their job.

Also, that guy needs his ears checked. The album is brilliant!

I love your comment e7. I'm guessing it's you as not many people go by the name Echo